The region's leading professional contractor

Painting vs. Replacing Siding: A Comparison

Two siding options are primarily open to Johnson City residents: painting and replacement. Both have pros and cons, making it challenging to decide what's best for your home. 

In this article, we'll take a closer look at the differences between painting and replacing siding so that you can make an informed decision.

Advantages of Painting Siding


siding replacement johnson city

Painting your siding is a relatively inexpensive option, especially when compared to replacing it.


Painting siding is relatively easy, especially if you do it yourself.


Siding painting is a task that takes only a short while to complete.

The Drawbacks of Painting Siding:


Painting the siding will only last as long as it takes to replace it.

May Not Last as Long

Painting the siding may only last for a short time before it needs replacing.

May Not Look as Good as Replacing Siding

Painting siding may look better than replacing it.

Preparation and Materials Needed When Painting Your Siding

Power washing

This will remove any dirt, grime, and other buildups that could prevent the paint from adhering correctly.

Caulking and sealing

You may need to caulk and seal cracks and gaps in your siding before painting. This will help prevent moisture from seeping in and causing damage.


Tape off any areas you don't want to paint, such as windows, doors, and trim.


You'll need a ladder to reach the top of your siding.

siding replacement johnson city


You'll need a paintbrush to apply the paint to your siding.

Paint roller

Apply the paint to your siding using a roller. This can make the job go faster and easier.

Paint sprayer

Use a paint sprayer to apply the paint to your siding. This can make the job go faster and easier.

Drop cloth

You'll need a drop cloth to catch any paint that drips or runs.

Pros of Replacing Siding


Replacing the siding will last longer than painting it.

More Durable

Instead of painting the siding, replacing it would be a more durable and long-lasting option.

Looks Better

Most of the time, it looks better to just replace the siding instead of painting it.

Cons of Replacing Siding


Having your siding replaced can be a pricey endeavour, particularly if you hire a contractor to do the work for you.


Putting new siding on the house can be time-consuming, especially if the homeowner does the work themselves.


The process of replacing your home's siding can disrupt both your home and your daily routine.

Preparation and Materials Needed When Replacing Your Siding

Remove the old siding

You'll need to remove the old one before installing the new one. This can be hard and take a lot of time, especially if your siding is attached to your house.

Repair any damage

You'll need to repair any damage to your house before installing the new siding. This includes damage to the sheathing, framing, and trim.

siding replacement johnson city

Install the new siding

You'll need to install the new siding according to the manufacturer's instructions. This can be time-consuming and difficult, especially if you're doing it yourself.

Caulk and seal

You will need to caulk and fill the new siding so that water doesn't get in and cause damage.

Paint or stain if you need help with what to do. They can assess your situation and help you make the best decision for your home.

Johnson City Roofing and Siding: Your siding replacement experts 

  • We are siding experts and can help you decide if siding replacement is the best option for your home.
  • We offer various siding materials and can help you find the perfect match for your home.
  • We provide siding installation services and can assist in making the procedure as simple and stress-free as possible.

If you're considering replacing the siding on your home, don't be afraid to get We are more than happy to respond to any of your inquiries and assist you in locating the ideal option for your residence. on for your home. 

Thank you for considering Johnson City Roofing and Siding!  

You might also like

Request a quote

* Free Coupon Once Completed *

    Call us today for stress free roofing!
    The region's leading professional contractor
    Working Hours
    Mon - Sat : 9:00 am - 6:00 pm
    Sun: Closed
    Privacy PolicyTerms of Conditions
    © 2024 Johnson City Roofing and Siding